Bad Advice, Good Advice
Harry Hurt III’s Off The Shelf review in the business section of the New York Times examines Nina DiSesa’s new book called “Seducing the Boys Club: Uncensored Tactics From a Woman at the Top”. According to Hurt, DiSensa encourages women to “seduce” and “manipulate” (referred to in the book as “S&M”, catchy enough and all the better to sell books, I guess) men at work and at home.
It is sad that the same year we have a woman running seriously for President, we are still getting bad advice about how to get ahead. So here’s some good advice for women who want to position themselves for success in a leadership role:
- Make Sure Key Players Openly Support You
Ask for open and unequivocal support from the people who put you in the job. After all, their success is tied to your success.
- Tap Into Networks
Establish your own “Advisory Board” comprised of people inside the firm as well as external mentors. Ask politically savvy people to guide you; seek feedback about your performance and the perception of your performance at every opportunity. Renew and strengthen relationships with people in your area of expertise as well as with potential referral sources.
- Hone Your Listening Skills
Figure out what people need (both clients and colleagues) by listening closely. Then help them to get it by offering creative solutions.
When a book as silly as DiSesa’s gets reviewed by The New York Times (even though it is not a good review) it is a bad thing for women. Exposure of these “tactics” promulgates mistrust of women – think about the brouhaha about whether or not Hillary Clinton’s show of emotion was “real”. Hurt writes that he finds DiSesa’s invocation of “persistent sexual stereotypes” to be depressing; I find it depressing that the book got reviewed at all.
TAGS: Harry Hurt III, Nina DiSesa, stereotypes, The New York Times










A few questions
Have you read the book?
As for Harry Hurt, I can only attribute his misguided review to the fact that as a man he is simply not in touch with his female side and therefore incapable of understanding what it takes to make it in a boys club.
Please, at least read the book before you go around telling women it’s bad advice.
I’m 38, work in a boys club and read the book and frankly it’s helped me more than any stereotypical pedantic advice ever did.
My advice to women — the only advice that counts is when it’s not borne of ignorance. So read the book form your own opinions and take it from me you’ll laugh along the way
Nina DiSesa is truly inspirational and wickedly enertaining.
Comment by Realist — February 18, 2008 @ 7:29 pm
Carol, I haven’t read the book but I agree that anytime someone (man or woman) is told to “seduce and manipulate” it can’t be good. Acting with integrity is an essential ingredient for long-term career success.
Comment by Dr. Lois Frankel — February 19, 2008 @ 8:12 pm